Immigration Policy
Center's page on Asian
Wisconzine

Constitutional Citizenship: A Legislative History

March 28, 2011

Washington, D.C. - Today, the Immigration Policy Center releases Constitutional Citizenship: A Legislative History by 14th Amendment
scholar Garrett Epps. One of the most insidious attacks on immigrants at both the federal and state level is the suggestion that the U.S.
should repeal the citizenship clause of the 14th Amendment and deny birthright citizenship to the children of certain immigrants. Some
proponents of this position argue that the Framers of the 14th Amendment never intended that birthright citizenship extend to the children of
temporary immigrants and unauthorized immigrants.

Epps argues that the Framers of the 14th Amendment lived during a period of increasing immigration, in which Chinese laborers were the
temporary immigrants of the day and "gypsies" were the unauthorized immigrants of the 19th century. The 14th Amendment provided for
birthright citizenship for both of these populations, and most certainly provides for birthright citizenship for the children of temporary and
unauthorized immigrants today.

Perhaps most fundamentally, Epps explains that the Framers of the 14th Amendment ere intent on changing the status quo and undoing
the impact of years of slavery. They sought to amend the Constitution and not replicate the discriminatory policies of the antebellum period.
A true analysis of the original intent of the Framers finds that they could not have intended to create a new population of vulnerable
persons who, because of the national origins or actions of their parents, are denied U.S. citizenship.

Epps writes: If the children of "illegal aliens" are "illegal" themselves, then we have taken a giant step toward recreating slavery in all but
name.  If citizenship is the hereditary gift of the nation rather than the inheritance of its people,  we are drifting back toward the discredited
doctrine of Dred Scott...The clamor for hereditary inequality comes from people eager to repeat the mistakes of the
American past, and by doing so, to betray the American future.

To view the piece in its entirety, see:

* Constitutional Citizenship: A Legislative History
[http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?llr=j7yeracab&et=1104983365389&s=37363&e=001JNzh-pTQQ4_qC1UvLr6ZQUyxO46UK02oHajq5y6o_da_e3imX
Zqi6bBK12WOOOnoaoshHOqnNWWPkLrJtx7IHOTmTJSBfQnnv7ve1M5FfFgVGBjS1mLljyHpoxxPgC-yL8rhfI50ITqNM3XHN8B3sIlHgHFCcu0
MrBHDTkDc9yaFCtEYeUwgozbdN7OodPj4IcU16dCPPG_8UlO-sN0Zyw==]
(IPC Special Report, March 28, 2011)